Cookies & Cream Butter Cups - Giften Market
Cookies & Cream Butter Cups - Giften Market
Cookies & Cream Butter Cups - Giften Market

Cookies & Cream Butter Cups

Regular price $6.00 Sale price$3.00 Save $3.00
  • In stock, ready to ship
  • Inventory on the way

Your favorite peanut butter cup but with a Cookies 'n Cream twist! A Belgian milk chocolate shell surrounds real crushed Oreo® pieces and Jessie’s delectable peanut butter filling. Top that off with a bit more Oreo® crumble for a treat that will bring out the kid in all of us.

These butter cups have a Shelf life of 6 months.

Each Pack contains 2 butter cups.

Ingredients: Peanuts, Belgian Milk Chocolate(Sugar, Cocoa Butter, Whole Milk Powder, Unsweetened Chocolate, Soy Lecithin, Natural Vanilla Flavor), Butter(Cream, Natural Flavor),Coffee, Powdered Sugar, Brown Sugar, Sea Salt 

Shop more Tasty Gifts. Shop all Birthday Gift Ideas.


Women Owned - Handmade - Small Batch - Not on Amazon

It all started when Jessie found a random peanut butter cup recipe online. While her first batch of peanut butter cups was good, she thought she could do better and it wasn't long before she realized there was quite a demand for quality peanut butter cups that go beyond the simple Peanut Butter and chocolate combination. Since then Jessie's Nutty Cups has turned into a flourishing business with a promise to maintain superior quality and to remain handmade to provide jobs for the community.

Estimated Shipping Widget will be displayed here! (with custom color)

We offer Flat Rate U.S. Shipping for $12.95 per address.

Shipping for Wine/Spirits gifts: $18.95-$22.95 .

Free shipping for orders $150+ per U.S. address (excludes group orders).

We are able to ship to street addresses, P.O. F.P.O. and A.P.O. boxes in all 50 U.S. states. International shipping is not currently available.

We strive to process orders as quickly as possible. Orders are typically processed and ready for shipment within two (2) business days. Transit time of 2-5 business days is typical. Delivery dates are not guaranteed.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Send a Care Package - Delivery Service

Small Business

Gifts They'll Love

When you shop Giften Market, you're supporting small businesses and the people behind them.

Create a Custom Care Package Online Service
Made in the USA

Our hardworking team hand packs each order with care.

Free Gift Message Card

Add your gift message at checkout!


Recently viewed



What an awesome experience. Everything was just great and on top of that - shipped on time and received on time. Amazing experience.

Sarah S.

I was able to pick and choose exactly what I wanted my recipient to get. She was delighted with everything. It was very easy and I heard that everything was beautifully arranged and wrapped.

Jennifer K.

The recipient of this gift called me immediately after receiving it to say how lovely it was and practical.

Joanne H.

We just got everything! My wife is obsessed! We already said everyone is getting gifts from Giften Market - we are very happy customers! 

Kristen M.

Wow....that was fast! Will order again! Thank you!

Cindy C.

Giften was a life saver during 2020 and they continue to be. So grateful to Martha (owner) for her speedy assistance. The options available are incredible.

Our employees loved receiving their gifts. Personalized and customized for every individual. Thank you Giften Market!

Alicia U.

Need Gifting Assistance?

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.